top of page
TZS FULL LOGO 04 2

The Chair In The Defense Room

Pablo Giacopelli
11 minutes ago
3 min read

Picture a quiet room at the end of a long corridor. A wooden table runs along one wall. Behind it sit the examiners, papers stacked in front of them, and pens already uncapped. 

 

Facing them is a single chair. You walk in carrying the thesis you finally took down from the shelf, and you stand in front of that table waiting for the questions to begin.

 

Why are you still standing?

 

Last time we opened the book of your life and discovered it had been a dissertation all along. Every doctorate ends with a defense which is the day a candidate faces a panel and answers for their work. What almost no one tells us is who sits on our panel.

 

Look closely at the faces behind the table.

 

The Committee We Appointed Ourselves

 

There is the coach who never smiled after a win. There is the parent whose approval arrived only when the grades did. There is the teacher who said you talked too much, the friend who left, and the voice that sounds like your own at three in the morning.

 

We gathered this committee slowly, one disappointment at a time, until every seat was filled. Every chapter we live gets handed across that table to be marked.

 

The strange thing about this panel is that it has never once awarded a pass.

In over ten years on the WTA tour I rarely met a player whose harshest critic was sitting in the stands. The crowd could be loud and the press could be cruel. None of it compared to the examiner who travelled inside her from tournament to tournament.

 

A player could win a match and walk off court replaying the three points she lost. The scoreboard said victory. The committee said not good enough.

 

Most of us have spent years defending our lives in front of people who were never qualified to grade them.


The Woman Who Stopped Defending

 

There is a woman in the Gospel of John who knew that room well. She came to the well in the heat of the day, when no one else would be there, because she had grown tired of the looks. 

 

Her story had already been read and marked by an entire town. Five husbands. A sixth who was not her husband. She had learned to walk the long way around people.

 

Yeshua was sitting at the well when she arrived. He asked her for a drink. Then he gently told her everything she had ever done.

 

She had every reason to brace herself. This was the moment the verdict would come.

 

It never came.

 

He read every page of her thesis and never reached for a red pen. He offered her a drink of living water instead. 

 

She ran back into the same town that had judged and graded her and told them to come and see a man who had told her everything she ever did. 

 

The chapters she had spent years hiding became the very words that opened other hearts.

 

Her story did not change. The one reading it did.

 

Changing the Reader

 

This is the invitation of the defense room. 

 

The goal is not to write a better thesis so the committee finally approves. The goal is to let someone else read it. 

 

Someone who sees the love behind the mistakes, the courage behind the fear, and the effort behind the stumble. When we are read with love we slowly learn to read ourselves the same way.

 

This takes practice. The old committee does not leave the room quietly. Each time one of those voices speaks consider asking a simple question. 

 

Would love say it like this? 

 

If the answer is no then you are allowed to let that examiner go because you were never on trial. You were always being welcomed.





Your Practice This Week

 

Take a quiet moment and picture the table in your own defense room. 

 

Notice who is sitting there. Name one voice you are ready to dismiss from the panel. Then write one sentence about a hard chapter of your life the way someone who deeply loves you would write it.

 

Read it slowly. Read it twice.

 

Now picture the room again. 

 

The table is empty and the papers are gone. The only thing left is the chair that was placed there for you from the very beginning. 

 

The One who reads your story is already seated. He is not waiting to grade you. He is waiting for you to finally join him.

 

With you in the journey,

 

 



PS See you next Sunday!

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page